Share On Social

Right-To-Repair Law Passes, Automakers File Federal Suit

While the legislation that passed in Massachusetts during the November election was targeted to the automotive industry, the same principle now applies to all equipment-servicing facilities in the state: When customers buy a piece of equipment (or car) they also buy complete access to the data streams that are generated during technical and diagnostic procedures as part of a service or maintenance job. The new Massachusetts law—which passed with 75% approval from voters—requires manufacturers to equip vehicles with standardized open data software platforms by 2022.

The legislation also states that such a standardized open data platform has to give vehicle owners and independent repair facilities direct access and the ability to retrieve mechanical data and run diagnostics through a mobile-based application.

Massachusetts voters had already passed landmark right-to-repair legislation in 2012 that required automakers to use a nonproprietary plug-in to access a machine’s onboard diagnostic port so third-party vendors could repair or service it, but that law had specifically exempted data that was transmitted wirelessly.

Yet as equipment systems and maintenance procedures have grown more sophisticated since the initial Massachusetts law was passed eight years ago, with more procedures and data now being handled online, right-to-repair advocates had taken up the wirelessly transmitted data exemption as an issue to overturn in future legislation.



Within weeks of the November election, automakers filed suit in a U.S. District Court in Massachusetts, primarily claiming that the law’s short timeline is impossible to meet when vehicle development cycles run three to five years.

Now, major automakers allege in a federal lawsuit filed after the election that the revised law poses cybersecurity and vehicle safety risks and the short timeline sets an “impossible task” for compliance.

The Alliance for Automotive Innovation — which represents General Motors, Ford, Toyota, Volkswagen and other automakers —filed the suit Nov. 20 in U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts, requesting that the court find the law “unenforceable because it is unconstitutional” and conflicts with federal laws.

Automakers are right to be concerned. Despite it’s relatively small size, Massachusetts’ requirement passed in 2012 requiring standard plug-ins to data ports was soon extended to cars nationwide, and the industry doesn’t want to see the same thing happen with data platforms.

On the face of it, the issue seems clear-cut: I bought it, I own it, and I need access to all hardware and software to repair it.

Manufacturers counter that consumers already have or can find all the information and equipment they need to handle all standard repairs and maintenance—but complete access that includes the ability to modify software settings poses serious safety, security and environmental risks.

According to the Outdoor Power Equipment Institute (OPEI), state legislation on the issue, in Massachusetts and in other states where similar laws have been proposed, is too broad and mixes the more acceptable right to repair with the unacceptable “right to modify.”

OPEI, as part of a coalition of suppliers, OEMs and groups including multiple dealer associations, has made its position clear in a statement of principles.

This includes a commitment from OPEI members to provide end users with increased resources by 2023 that includes fleet management information, electronic field diagnostic tools and all related information and materials.

However, OPEI and its members draw the line at allowing third parties to alter or reset security features such as immobilizer systems, reprogram engine control units, change any settings related to emissions or safety compliance or access any embedded software or code.

Latest News

Rotary Adds NJ, Eastern Penn. Manager

Rotary Corp. has appointed Ralph Baron territory manager for New Jersey and eastern Pennsylvania, according to an announcement by Mark Smith, Chief Sales Officer. Baron was previously a sales…

Stihl Launches New Learning Management System

The new and improved Stihl iCademy free web-based training platform is primarily designed for independent Stihl dealers and their employees, and is also accessible for vocational training. The…

Walbro Makes Organizational Changes

Walbro, LLC has announced an organizational restructuring build around three autonomous business units—each business unit will have its own operations, engineering, finance, sales, program…

VP Racing To Add Business Development Focus

VP Racing Fuels, Inc., a global leader in performance fuels, lubricants and additives, has announced the appointment of James McVey to Business Development to focus on the OEM business. “James…